Sometime back in 2007, an unruly gang of statisticians working for the government sat in a room and decided that finding out the total amount of pizza places existing in Manhattan was a research mission worthy of taxpayer money. And apparently nobody argued with them, because at the end of the year, they concluded their research and turned in their results: just over 1600 places serving up pizza in NYC.
What they failed to do, was narrow it down to a list that might suggest which of those ~1600 are serving pizza worth eating. And that’s where we pick things up—because navigating the pizza realm in NYC is no simple task. Below you’ll find 7 of the pizza spots worth having a bite at in NYC (a strikingly 0.4% of the total places), as well as each spot’s pie that comes highly recommended. No taxpayer money was used in assembling this list.
1. Joe’s Pizza
Recommended pies: Plain Pie. You won’t be mad about it.
Location: 7 Carmine St., New York, NY
More info: www.joespizzanyc.com
Recommended pies: The Vodka Pizza.
Location: 235 Mulberry St., New York, NY
More info: www.rubirosanyc.com
Recommended pie: Their Grandma Pie is the real deal.
Location: 511 E 5th St., New York, NY
More info: www.ggsnyc.com
Recommended pies: Thin crust + deep dish. Trust us.
Location: 50 MacDougal St., New York, NY
More info: www.emmettsnyc.com
Recommended pies: The Calabrese. Thick-cut pepperoni, fennel sausage, red onions, pomodoro and mozzarella.
Location: 160 Second Ave., New York, NY
More info: www.nicolettapizza.com
Recommended pies: Go with The Funghi. Fontina, mozzarella, hen of the woods, yellow foots, red onion and thyme.
Location: 29 E 29th St., New York, NY
More info: www.martamanhattan.com
7. Pizza Beach
Recommended pies: The Margherita is on point.
Location: 167 Orchard St., New York, NY
More info: www.pizzabeachclub.com